AI In Books and Art

Hannah Brixton on Instagram

What is your relationship with generative AI, as either creator or consumer?
I suspect I consume much more AI generated content than I realize. I often share things with the kids online and the response is, “Mother that is AI.” I’m better at spotting it now but I am possibly the most gullible person I know, so I will likely continue to be duped.
The song I have written about and linked to the last two posts is AI generated. The artist also has a visual art platform and is very clear that all of their content is AI generated, does not exist in real life, and cannot be produced by or purchased from them.
What do we think of this?

Most creators I know are strongly opposed to generative AI in any form and any domain of art or creative work. Human work is pirated without creators’ authorization, knowledge, or compensation to teach AI platforms. Rare books in print have been obtained and destroyed to scan for teaching large language models and now AI generated books enter the market without consistent transparency on their ‘creative’ origin.

What are the benefits and costs of this practice? I don’t use generative AI (that I know of, do I?) so I can’t comment on the former. And I can’t say I have experienced the latter directly, either. So my words here are theoretical for me and of low credibility.

It behooves us all, however, to consider our own ethical and operational interactions with this novel–what do we call it, intelligence? Device? Tool? Entity? How much do we care about the human creators whose work we take for granted, and whose livelihoods may suffer greatly from mindless and uninformed consumption of AI products?

I don’t think any of us wants to harm anyone else with our choices of books or art. The landscape is dense with uncontrolled growth and predators in hiding, operating unfettered in an unregulated online economy with no accountability that I can observe. Yikes.

So the questions are:
–How can I learn more about how generative AI affects human creators and consumers, both positively and negatively, as well as the environment and other entities I may not think of?
–If my fellow humans are harmed by this new technology, how much do I relate my own use to that harm and what level of harming use am I willing to tolerate? What if I multiply that by everybody I know, or everybody in my region, or the world; how does that change the calculation?
–There will always be those who tell me it doesn’t matter, the technology is here to stay and one person can’t stop it. How do I assess my own power and influence on the large scale movement of AI through the humanities?
–How can I use AI responsibly and encourage others to do so? What does that mean?
–What guardrails do we need on AI to not lose our humanity to machines, our creativity to algorithms, and our connections to — nothing?

Neither a ‘burn it down’ nor a ‘who cares’ mindset will help here. We need elevated awareness and thoughtful engagement on the part of creators, consumers, and regulators (legislators and enforcement entities). Just thinking about it makes me incredibly pessimistic.

For myself, I will try to minimize my interaction with and consumption of AI generated products. I will actively support and amplify human creators I know and love.

In service of amplification, please find below panels from romance author Hanna Brixton’s excellent explanation of generative AI’s effect on independent authors. There is also a panel from romance author Lauren Smith’s Facebook account on how readers can avoid contributing to AI theft of authors’ intellectual property by using AI summaries of their books.

We can all educate ourselves and learn the real world, small and large scale, human and earthly consequences of this burgeoning, uncontrolled technology. It is here to stay; we get to decide where and how to spend our energy interacting with it while protecting our friends and human creators from its deleterious effects. The more thoughtfully we each individually act, the more we can expect our leaders to do so also. We can make a difference.

Hannah Brixton on Instagram
Hannah Brixton on Instagram
Hannah Brixton on Instagram
Hannah Brixton on Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Hannah Brixton, Instagram
Lauren Smith, Facebook June 2024

Leave a Reply